Bluehost

Stats & Analysis For October 2008 – $1,153 Earned

November 3, 2008 Posted under: Making Money Online by Caroline Middlebrook

Income

Total Income Earned for October 2008 – $1,153.02

Nice to see the income pop back into 4 figures this month. Actually I think something went wrong with last months stats as I got an affiliate payment from Blog Mastermind into my PayPal account a couple of weeks ago but their reports were showing all zero’s for September so I think it was just playing up on the day I did the stats! Oh well, it’s always nice to get unexpected money!

Subscribers

Aweber which manages the email list (now called The Bloggers Bible), and Feedburner which manages the RSS feed for the blog, have been integrated for some time now which means that the number you see in my sidebar is a combination of both subscriptions. Usually in these stat posts I separate out RSS subscribers to those who have subscribed to the email list so I can track the growth separately. However yesterday when I introduced the lightbox popup which advertises the Bloggers Bible it made me re-think the whole idea of these two subscriptions.

Obviously some people don’t like the lightbox and some people have gone so far as to say they’d unsubscribe from the blog as a result. What does that really mean for me? What does it mean for me to have a blog subscriber v a Bloggers Bible reader? Blog readers are lovely – they let me know that what I am saying is not falling on deaf ears. They leave me interesting comments and most importantly of all, they feed my ego! Occasionally, but not often, they’ll buy something! What does a reader of my list mean to me? They don’t comment or offer feedback because there is no mechanism to allow them to do so. They have asked for information and they are getting it and more often than blog readers, they buy something.

Obviously both types of readers are highly valuable to me but does it really matter how each one grows? My lightbox has now been active for around 48 hours and signups have increased significantly (much faster than I would ever expect to see RSS readership grow) but it is possible that I will see a drop in RSS subscribers as a result. When I really thought about this I realised that all that really matters is that my readers are on the increase. If I piss off a few people with the lightbox and they unsubscribe from the blog (guys – use an RSS reader!!), but gain a whole bunch of readers to the Bloggers Bible then my overall readership has increased all that’s all I am interested in. As an early indicator, this shows the effect of the lightbox so far:

So, from now on, I’m just going to lump them both together but I’ll try to report the numbers a bit more clearly. I haven’t posted an RSS graph this month as Feedburner had two of it’s annoying blips which slash your subs in half which also screws up the nice pretty graph.

Subs at End of September: 3,260

Subs at End of October: 3,557

Total new Subscribers in October: 297

Last month I had a bit of a flatline but the growth seems to be back to normal this month which is nice. Hitting 3,500 is a nice milestone. It would be nice to hit 4000 by the end of the year. Even though the readership is small compared to the likes of Darren Rowse (who has a mind boggling 66,000!) if I try to imagine what it would look like to have all of those people standing in a room and listening to me speaking it’s quite something!

Traffic

Traffic is pretty much the same as always though with the exception of one spike it has been so flat this month that you can clearly see in the traffic graph just where each weekend is, as there is a little dip over the weekends. Seems people only make money online during the week :-)

One trend that I am seeing though is a slow and steady increase in search engine traffic and decrease in social traffic which would seem to correspond with my reduced activity in the social sites. Even though traffic levels have remained largely consistent over the last few months, where it is coming from is slowly shifting. Search engine traffic is always a good thing because it doesn’t require maintenance. This is unlike social traffic which requires constant participation to continue to bring in large benefits.

Amusing Keywords

I don’t usually pay much attention to the keywords that send me traffic as I just write about whatever I feel like and don’t pay all that much attention to SEO (maybe I should now that I am getting so much more search traffic than I used to!) but I did notice a phrase that made me laugh near the top of my stats. “caroline middlebrook is a loser” brought me 43 visitors! I tried the search myself but nothing came up so I’m not too sure where that came from but you’re know you’re famous when that many people are doing searches like that :-)

So, amused by that one I had a dig through to see if I could come up with any other amusing ones:

“i want to be rich”

“keep it dirty”

“lolcats look at my balls”

“ethics of begging”

“monetize my porno collection”

“find out when cats puke and when its bad for them”

“I’ll keep your dirty secret”

Conclusion

Much the same this month but I feel as though the introduction of the lightbox to plug the new Bloggers Bible is going to have quite a positive impact on overall subscriber levels. I’ll be monitoring it closely and tweaking it on a weekly basis to make it as effective as possible. Judging from the early results, it is here to stay so If you are one of the people who does not like it and would prefer not to see it but you still want to read my blog, I can highly recommend the offline RSS reader called Feed Demon.

This is now free software (I had to pay for my copy!) and it’s great. One of my favourite features is that it synchronises with newsgator an online reader which means that you can install it on multiple computers (I have it on my desktop PC and on my laptop) and they are both kept in sync. And because its an offline reader, there’s no ads, unlike some of the online ones.


Want to Make Money Blogging? My free course, The Bloggers Bible contains everything you need to know about building a highly popular and profitable blog from scratch!

Just fill in your email below to get your first lesson immediately:


Post to Twitter Tweet This Post Post to StumbleUpon Stumble This Post


You might also like these similar posts:

Stats & Analysis for October ‘09 – $5,937 Earned
The Power of the Cookie
February Income Boosted by Blog Mastermind
Stats & Analysis for November ‘09 – $732 earned
Stats & Analysis For June 2008 – $808 Earned

30 Comments:

Hey Caroline,

Good for your for choosing to keep the lighbox. You are the master and at the end of the day you are the one who closes the till.

As to the RSS reader, how is it better than Google Reader or BlogLines? Both are clean from ads and can be accessed from Anywhere.
Actually I recently made the switch from BlogLines to Google Reader for convenience (one less password to remember)..

Cheers,
Alex

Alex at Net-Entrepreneur.coms last blog post..I like to cook, but this is too much…

Andy Bacon
November 3, 2008

Hi Caroline,
I agree with you in your argument for or against a sign-up. The question really is what are you spending all this time working on-line for. If it is to build a blog where a lot of people like what you have to say, then don’t push subscriptions. But if you are trying to run a business then you need to do what is necessary to monetize your content.
Some people may unsubscribe but were they really doing anything other than getting a free ride anyway?
Just so you know, I tried to visit the page from the previous post where you started the lightbox a few times and there seems to be a problem. Sometimes it pops up and sometimes not. When it is there I can’t find a way through.
Thanks for all the help you give.
Andy BAcon

Andy Bacons last blog post..What Is The Number One Question For Your Success?

Conrad Hees
November 3, 2008

Hey caroline, good post

I think that that is extremely funny that ‘caroline middlebrook is a loser’ brought you so many visitors! People can search for mean names for me all day if it will bring me traffic like that!

Keep up the good work, i enjoy what you are doing with your blog lately.

Conrad Heess last blog post..The 5 Lessons that Obama Can Teach Us About Self-Marketing

sven
November 3, 2008

It’s nice to see that even months after you published your ebook you are still making money from the referrals, or do people actually click on the bluehost ad on top of your page?

Ruchir Chawdhry
November 3, 2008

“monetize my porno collection”

LOL that one was funny. And what’s more funny is that you rank # 3 & #4 for it!

Ruchir Chawdhrys last blog post..GMail Labs Adds "Canned Responses": Save Time With FAQs

small hosting
November 3, 2008

For me, you are the best blogger, because you are willing to share you VALUABLE knowledge. I do can learn a lot from you. My pageview is just 60% of your pageview, but my revenue is way below you.

small hostings last blog post..johnchow.com Revenue Report

Franklin Bishop
November 3, 2008

I think it is more important to go for e-mail subscribers then getting RSS subscribers. I’d rather have a bunch of e-mails because they’re so easy to monetize. I think you are already heading in the right direction and you will be making more and more money if you monetize it right.

Franklin Bishops last blog post..5 Types of Blog Posts for More Traffic

Following Franklin’s comment,

I think RSS is way overestimated. It’s way more productive to concentrate on your email subscribers which are a real asset.

Try to convert those RSS subscribers to email.. there’s a challenge for you.

Way to go overall

Cheers,
Alex

Alex at Net-Entrepreneur.coms last blog post..I like to cook, but this is too much…

Jeff Jones
November 3, 2008

Hi Caroline,

I totally agree with you and the others who said you’ve got to make sure you produce quality content for everybody but the number that matters most is email subscribers.

It’s way too easy to not worry about your list and later realizing you have no way to establish a business relationship with any of your readers.

Jeff

Gil
November 3, 2008

Congrats on getting back into the 4 figure income bracket!

hmmm… “find out when cats puke and when its bad for them”
I would guess when they are not feeling well, and I can’t imagine it ever being good for them.

How would Google explain how that relates to your blog?

Gils last blog post..Evolution of a Niche Site

Bill Stevens
November 3, 2008

Blogger’s Bible – From the book of Caroline, Chapter One, Verse 1 – “Blog readers are lovely – they let me know that what I am saying is not falling on deaf ears.” Sorry, couldn’t resist.

Also, here’s another reader Digital Inspiration mentioned – RSS Bandit

Thanks for the update on your lightbox. It will be interesting to see where this goes with subscribers. When I’m an avid reader of a blog I usually don’t care what pops up.

Bill Stevenss last blog post..10 Social Media Resource Tweets

Paddy Bloggit
November 4, 2008

I’ve been reading your blog on FeedDemon for a while Caroline and I also have John Chow on it. He has google ads on his feeds …. so rock on stick some google ads on your rss feed. :-)

Paddy Bloggits last blog post..Duckett’s Grove

Hugh
November 4, 2008

lol nice random keywords huhuhu

Hughs last blog post..Advertise on The Cheezburger Network for $1 Billion

Dunk
November 4, 2008

“monetize my porno collection” now that gives me an idea lol.

BTW your now No.1 in google for the search term hehe

Dunks last blog post..Polar Bear Mount For Sale?

Mike Huang
November 4, 2008

Great to see a big comeback Caroline. I have also noticed that lightbox and absolutely hate it. I have mentioned that to John and Shoe too, but they don’t care, they won’t lose ANY traffic from it.

You’re also very lucky to have such dedicated and continuous referrals for Bluehost. Even if you stopped this blog, you would continue to earn a least $500/month :D

-Mike

Caroline Middlebrook
November 4, 2008

@Alex, it’s a matter of preference really. I never liked the way either of those two looked, I just like Feed Demon :-)

@Andy, yes there will always be some people online who want everything for free (mind you, all I am plugging is more free information hehe!), and will always object to ads of any kind and never spend anything. It may sound callous, but those people will never help your bottom line if you are looking to make a living.

The lightbox is set to only display once every couple of days so it shouldn’t be popping up every page anymore. Once you’ve seen it for the first time on any visit, you shouldn’t see it again that day.

@sven, yes they do strangely enough!

@Ruchir, I’ll probably rank even higher for it with the help of this post lol!

@Alex, I’m not really looking to convert my RSS readership into something else as I do like having my little following here! What I’m really trying to do is build up a separate readership via the email list. There will be a certain degree of overlap of course but I’m quite happy to build both and have different audiences and goals for each.

@Paddy, heh yes I have seen John’s RSS ads. I’ve never wanted AdSense of any kind on this blog so there are no plans to implement something like that anytime soon!

@Mike, yeah residual income sure is nice! Now the next goal is to turn that $500 into $6,000 :-)

Justin
November 4, 2008

I lol’d at the keyword part. Someone prob just searched that phrase multiple times to make it appear in your logs. Evil, but effective spamming I guess.

Yeah, you should focus heavily on SEO. You get fairly nice traffic and have a good following independent of SEO. Some solid SEO would prob go a long way.

You should just do some solid SEO on the home page for a major keyword, then you could simply track back any links you got from your readers and ask for some optimized anchor text. You seem well liked, so you could grab some nice anchored links quickly.

Justins last blog post..Affiliate Networks for Making Money

Cath Lawson
November 4, 2008

Hi Caroline – well done. That’s a decent amount of cash for the number of readers.

I used a newsletter when my blog was new and after seeing your results, I think I’ll re-introduce it. It certainly seems like a bigger percentage of people buy through a newsletter. By the way, one of my readers just bought your Traffic Rush course and she thinks it’s absolutely fantastic.

I like your lightbox. They do put some people off but I found I got a much higher sign up rate using one. And you can always experiment with using it when folk are leaving your blog too, as well as when they arrive.

Like you, I’ve had some funny searches. I wonder if some of these people type the search terms in the box on your site to annoy you. No joke I’ve had searches for “name naked” for just about every single female commenter on my blog. That has to be someone playing a prank.

Peter
November 4, 2008

Hi Caroline
have yo been ignoring me? LOL.

>>>“caroline middlebrook is a loser” brought me 43 visitors<<<

I’m flumaxed as to what “content” these people were expecting?
Nice of Google to point them to the horses mouth ;-)

But what sort of attitude do these people have?
If they applied that much energy to being proactive about their own business, they might not need to seach to revel in your negativty.

I’m one who will hate the lightbox, especially if it will appear every visit and not just once every month or similar, which most allow settings for. The one I bought does for sure.

I had 1 on 1 of my sites, but Gogole TOS will not allow you to PPC promote a landing page with a pop-up or pop-off on.
Something for people to take note of! I prefer pop-offs as they don’t instantly get in teh way of why you came.

The main thing that strike sme is I did not knwo about Bloggers Bible before the lightbox brought it rudely to my attention.
What I mean is I didn’t notice you talk about it on Twitter and I haven’t noticed it in your own promotional areas on your blog.

That seem to be an issue with blogs in that it is the last article that gets the attention. If you have soemthign fixed you want to pormote, it is mor edifficult. Using a static front page and people think your blog hasn;t changed.

I guess this concept is in the bloggers bible?

Peace and light
Peter
Getting It LIVE 2008 November 14th 12 Noon Est. BE THERE!

Carrie
November 4, 2008

Congrats on the earnings, Caroline.

Good too see you head back up after last month, hopefully that trend continues.

Carries last blog post..Niche Site Building – Progress Update

BusinessX
November 4, 2008

Allow me to give you kudos for keeping the lightbox too. Thank for the diligent reporting of income, a highlight of my online month. This is what makes you blog so real and worth coming back.

J.
November 4, 2008

lolz..
btw, this month you’ll have another unique visitor for “caroline middlebrook is a loser” aka ‘me’… I just had to search for that term after reading your post and got this post as a result (i did click on it though just to add another visitor to you stats for keyword “caroline middlebrook is a loser”) :)
well, this isn’t really the right post for this, but I just wanted to tell you that i thoroughly enjoy reading your blog… I dont really remember how I reached your blog, but I’ve been hooked. Every visit of mine ends up with 5-10 page views… Needless to say, I’m on your list, and just subscribed to Bloggers Bible today.

Abdul
November 4, 2008

Hey caroline,
First of all congratulations on your income, and I’m glad you made some money off the Stumble-rush thing as well, I was subscribed to that as well. I would like to learn how you get a lot of traffic from Google.

Abduls last blog post..When Google Found it and Indexed it

Anthony
November 5, 2008

Ok, this made me laugh…

“find out when cats puke and when its bad for them”

HAHAHA!!!

Oh, that’s the funniest thing i’ve heard all day.

Thanks for sharing :)

A.

http://ipodmarket.com.au – Find The Best Price on the New iPod Nano Chromatic

Nice stats, the money is always a great propeller to move forward.

Caroline Middlebrook
November 5, 2008

@Justin, I’ve often thought about a main keyword for this blog in general but I just can’t think of one. “make money online” is heavily competed on and “internet marketing” even more so. I’m not sure what else would fit.

@Cath, heh that’s a weird way to try and annoy me! Why would I get annoyed at traffic, it just makes me laugh :-)

@Peter, that particular search had quotes around it so I wonder if perhaps one person typed it in and then it appeared in a ‘recent searches’ section which made other people click it just to see what it was. But as you say, people love gossip and a scandal.

Yes the lightbox has a setting to be displayed every X number of days. I have it set to 2 at the moment but that it something I will experiment with in the coming weeks.

The reason you didn’t know about Bloggers Bible is because I didn’t announce it. I got the idea for it, implemented it and launched it with the lightbox all in the space of 24 hours. It was not planned – just one of those spur of the moment things :-)

Olakunle Solomon Fatoye
November 8, 2008

1. Dearly Beloved Caroline:
2. Greetings!
3. Just a quick one; you are always on the mark when you focus on what works.
4. For one, I have always believed in hitting the nail on the head for every idea.
5. The subscription lightbox is a way to go, I have seen that work many times and when I talk of high subscription rates, that is one of the clues. There is a very slim chance of bypassing the subscription and sometimes people even sign up more than once trying to make sure they are on the list.
6. For every action, there will always be a reaction and your choice in this matter is key. You decide what is best for you and all that cares about your views. To avoid all reactions, do nothing. Action however makes the difference.
7. Remember also that opposites attract as in the beginning it may seem like you are stepping on toes but in the end it might become the norm and you will be making friends. In the fact and of the truth, likes repel. There is always bravery involved with making changes.
8. Thank you for your time all the ways in nurturing this blog.
9. Remain blessed and a blessing with God speed.
10. Regards, Olakunle Solomon Fatoye.

Olakunle Solomon Fatoyes last blog post..5 Free Ways to Promote your Website

Caroline Middlebrook
November 8, 2008

@Olakunle, these days I have learned that there will always be the loud voices of the few who complain, are negative and son on but these loud voices don’t represent the silent masses. I listen the voices of my stats hehe :-)

DR
November 10, 2008

Building an email list for a newsletter is something I’ve often thought about, but never done. I’ve signed up for yours, and look forward to reading the content. As for the pop-up box, I would think most of your RSS readers would never see it unless they came to the site. Can it be set up only to show to search engine visitors?

DRs last blog post..How to Pick a Lucrative Online Money Making Topic

Caroline Middlebrook
November 11, 2008

@DR, no this particular kind of box can’t differentiate between different sources of visitors but who knows what functionality Aweber may introduce. However there is a plugin that does that – it allows you to control the ads you display and who to but I don’t use AdSense here so I’ve not tried it.


2 Trackbacks:

Free UnBlockable PopUp Software | MasonWorld Internet Marketing Strategy | Internet Based Marketing Blog

[...] (pop-under, pop-over, light boxes, etc.).  I was motivated to do this based on results pop-up optin results published by  Caroline Middlebrook.  She published the graph below on Twitter to show the dramatic impact of the lightbox on he [...]

Stats & Analysis for November ‘08 - $1,392 Earned | Caroline Middlebrook

[...] last months stats post I had only just introduced the lightbox popup advertising the Bloggers Bible and I anticipated that [...]

Leave a comment

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

CommentLuv Enabled


Recommended Services
MyBlogLog Community
Top Commentators
Copyright © Caroline MiddlebrookTheme designed by Design Farmer

Twitter links powered by Tweet This v1.6.1, a WordPress plugin for Twitter.