Bluehost

Link Building #1 – Social Bookmarking

November 10, 2008 Posted under: Promotion by Caroline Middlebrook

AdSense project

This next part of the project with focus on the link building methods I have been using to drive backlinks to the niche sites to help them rank for their chosen keywords. The first technique that I use is called social bookmarking but as this is the first post in the series I’ll also give a short introduction to link building in general and why we want to do it.

The Purpose of Link Building

To give a very simplistic view of link building, if Google sees two web pages that have been equally optimised for a particular keyword, then it will look at the backlinks to determine which one to rank higher. There’s only so much you can do in terms of on-page optimisation. Once you have your keyword in your title, your url, tags, sprinkled throughout your text, perhaps in image tags and so on, at that point anything else that you do to the page itself will have minimal impact and it all falls down to backlinks.

Not all Link Building is Equal

You can get a little bit too simplistic and think that it is just about the number of links but that is not so. There are many factors that determine how valuable a particular backlink is, for example:

  • Whether or not it has the “no-follow” tag
  • The PageRank of the linking page
  • The anchor text used in the link
  • The relevancy of the linking page to the target page

The best quality backlink would therefore be a do-followed (or, lack of no-follow to be accurate), high PR link from a relevant site using the anchor text of your target keyword. A poor quality backlink would be a no-follow link from a PR0 site that has no relevancy to your site and uses totally irrelevant anchor text. Just one good quality backlink can be equivalent to thousands of low quality ones – it is not just about quantity!

With regards to PageRank there is a rough formula that states that a PR1 backlink is worth 10 PR0’s and a PR2 is worth 10 PR1’s and so on. So you can imagine the power of getting even just a handful of backlinks from relevant PR6 or above sites!

Poor Quality Backlinks Are Better Than No Backlinks!

Some people get obessive about the quality of backlinks and refuse to employ certain types of link building methods deeming them as inferior to the good quality links that I describe above. However, even a very low quality link is worth more than no link at all. However there are exceptions… if you get backlinks from what Google determines is a ‘bad neighbourhood’ then that backlink can actually hurt you. You don’t want to be getting backlinks from porn sites, gambling sites, or anything that seems dubious! But other than that, it is worth getting all the links you have time for.

How Does Social Bookmarking Help Build Links?

Social bookmarking is a bit like your browser favourites but stored online on a website rather than on your computer and associated with a browser. The social part comes into play by those bookmarks being public which allows other people to see what you have bookmarked. There are tons of these kinds of sites around and there are some subtle differences between some of them which I’ll discuss in a moment.

The cool thing about this practice is that you can bookmark the individual content pages of your site and not just the home page. This is called ‘deep linking’ and its a good thing to do because very often it will be an individual page on your site that ranks for your keyword and not necessarily the home page. Not only that but because there are so many of these bookmarking sites to use, if you get into the habit of submitting every piece of content to a bunch of them you can build quite a lot of backlinks fairly quickly.

Do-Follow Social Bookmarking SItes

Over a year ago I wrote a post which listed around 20 social bookmarking sites that were do-follow. Most of them either use the no-follow tag or they use some internal linking mechanism that hides the real URL and so does not count as a backlink. This post is one of my highest trafficked posts on this blog and to keep it relevant I update it every couple of months. The last update was at the beginning of October.

I suggest you start with that post. The list in that post is what I have used to bookmark all the content from my niche sites for this project and I use the method described in the post. However, that post is a list of what I call ‘pure bookmarking’ sites – I do not include any site that has any kind of voting system. The reason for this is described at length in another post I wrote about social bookmarking vs story submission but the essence is this: when you link to your content at a pure bookmarking site, you are just storing it for your later retrieval. But when you link to your content page at a site that has a voting element you are effectively saying to the community, “hey look at my page – I think you’ll like it, please vote for it”. Now that is absolutely fine if your content is relevant and therein lies the problem for so many Internet marketers that begin with this bookmarking without fully understanding it.

Sites like Social Marker make it very easy to bookmark your link to a whole bunch of sites at once but they lump them all together – they will even throw StumbleUpon in there and I have also warned of the dangers of including StumbleUpon in your social bookmarking efforts. When you submit to a site that allows the community to vote, you must be respectful of the kind of content that the community likes. Why? Well firstly it’s the right thing to do, but for the ethically challenged – not doing so gets your account banned so it is simply a waste of time not to play by the rules.

Guidelines for Responsible Bookmarking

This is one of those areas that can venture into spam if you’re not careful but where do you draw the line? Well let’s get one thing straight here – bookmarking sites want your links! Without them they would not exist so don’t feel bad for using many of them in your link building campaign. However, what they don’t want is fake accounts, duplicate content, spam content and so on.

I’ve been getting irritated by some of the shortfalls of social bookmarker and have been looking around for some better automated tools. The best of the bunch seems to be one called Bookmarking Demon but I won’t link to it as I don’t recommend it. The copy of the sales letter seems to promote spam. They advertise a feature to allow you to automatically create an unlimited number of accounts at the sites so you can bookmark the same links over and over! This is pure spam! So even though some of the features of the tool look good, I can’t bring myself to buy it though I’d be interested to hear opinions of those who have used it.

So some guidelines to follow – have only one account at each site, and bookmark each page only once. Secondly, think about SEO before submitting. When using a tool such as social marker to speed things up its easy to get lazy and just do it as quickly as possible but then you are missing out on the benefits. The idea of link building is to increase the keyword authority of the pages within your site. Most of the bookmarking sites will want a title, a description and some tags as well as the link. Make sure your primary keyword is in all of those places and don’t forget to use tags for those awkward keywords that are difficult to write for.

Lastly, I don’t have a list of social news sites such as Digg, Reddit and so on but I know a man who does :-) There was a blog called Traffickd which I think has stopped publishing now but they have posted a great list of social sites organised into niches. There are other such lists on the Internet if you Google around. Find your niche, find relevant social sites in that niche and add those to your submission routine.

One last point but its a trickier one to implement – ideally, you would spread out your backlinks over time. This is especially relevant if you have an existing site and have not used this method. Don’t go and bookmark all your pages in one go and add hundreds of links at once because Google will view that as suspicious. Social marker is an immediate service unfortunately so if you want to spread your links out over a period of days you have to do it manually. But a reasonable guideline to follow is – don’t bookmark more than one page from the same domain in any one day. What should you do if you are using this technique with a busy site that publishes lots of content daily? Simple – pick the best piece of content each day and bookmark that, leave the rest.

I’m actually thinking of developing my own social bookmarking tool to overcome these issues. It would also be nice if it could run completely on auto-pilot – you just load it up with your information, click a button and let it build those links slowly over the next few days.

Right now this is just an idea and I’m not even sure if there is any real demand for such a tool. If you would be interested then join my notification list below and if I see enough response I’ll begin working on it and use the list to let you know of any developments:

Link Building with Social Bookmarking Sites Summary

Here are the golden rules:

  1. Only bookmark good content, don’t bookmark your porn site!
  2. Only bookmark one page from a domain in one day
  3. Use only one account at every site
  4. Bookmark at all the generic bookmarking sites
  5. Bookmark at a handful of niche-specific sites
  6. Always optimise your submissions for SEO

Want to Make Money Blogging? My free course, The Bloggers Bible contains everything you need to know about building a highly popular and profitable blog from scratch!

Just fill in your email below to get your first lesson immediately:


Post to Twitter Tweet This Post Post to StumbleUpon Stumble This Post


You might also like these similar posts:

Social Bookmarking Can Kill Your StumbleUpon Traffic!
17 Social Sites To Spam For Backlinks
A Reader Asks Some Blogging Questions
Some Oldies But Goodies (Blog Posts That Is)
Social Bookmarking v Story Submission for Self Promotion

30 Comments:

Mike Smith
November 10, 2008

Definitely one of the better posts I’ve read this week. Caroline, you’ve got a great site here and I intend on keeping up with it. *found your link through twitter*

Thanks,
Mike

Mike Smiths last blog post..15 CANT MISS Project Management App Options

Good guide for the newcomers, Caroline.

Other topics you could’ve thrown in are:
* What happens when you have too many backlinks all at once
* The time it takes to see the results of your efforts
* The effects on your PR
* Then will you see your PR increase
* Reciprocal links, why is it a bad idea
* Buying links, the pros and cons

Cheers,
Alex

Alex at Net-Entrepreneur.coms last blog post..I like to cook, but this is too much…

Jonathan Hunt
November 10, 2008

Hi Caroline,

It was my understanding that there isn’t really such a thing as a ‘bad link’ – just a worthless one?

It would make sense, as otherwise your competitors could intentionally create these bad links and you would be peanalised for something you have no control over.

Jonathan Hunts last blog post..Are Fancy Rats Expensive?

Mike Huang
November 11, 2008

Just bookmark all your pages on all the social bookmarking and get the links :P I know it’s bad to do it yourself, but you can just create like 5 accounts and alternate. These are bad practices, but work nonetheless.

-Mike

Dennis Edell
November 11, 2008

Caroline – “Only bookmark one page from a domain in one day” – you mean “per site” right?

Dennis Edells last blog post..Did You Know You Can Refund Domain Names?

Money Saving Tips
November 11, 2008

@Dennis Edell – Uh no, book marking one page per site is stupid and you would barely get traffic or a “decent” backlink. Bookmarking sites on occasion is the best thing you can do.

Money Saving Tipss last blog post..Savin at namecheap in november 2008

BusinessX
November 11, 2008

I appreciate you continually updating your social bookmarking post. When I first went looking for dofollow lists, it was irritating to find lists and almost half of the list was outdated in one form or another- site down, not updated for extended periods of time, or went nofollow.

Caroline Middlebrook
November 11, 2008

@Alex, I don’t think reciprocal links are a bad idea. One way links are better but as I said in the post, any link is better than no link!

@Jonathan, you may be right there, I’m not an expert in this area.

@Mike, but with so many sites around there’s simply no point spamming them with multiple accounts!

@Dennis, depends what you mean by site. If you have two “sites” that are separated only by subdirectory, Google would see those as being on the same domain and therefore as one ’site’. So no, don’t build too many links to one domain in one go.

@BusinessX, yeah I have looked at a few of those lists when first building mine and it was a nuisance. I’m lucky that it gets many comments and people continually let me know of new sites.

nudgeme
November 11, 2008

Hi Caroline

I just had to leave a comment for this brilliant post. I’ve read loads on backlinks, but nothing comes close to this clear, step by step, concise explanation about how it all works – esp things like bookmarking sites and the voting ones being better and also niche social sites. I’m going to check out your links you give on this now, but your posts are just consistently more useful than so many others, which is so refreshing.

Thanks for sharing, it’s appreciated.

All the best

Tamsin/nudgeme

Dennis Edell
November 11, 2008

Oops no, “per site” meant as in bookmarking sites. One page of my site per one bookmarking site….that make more sense?

Dennis Edells last blog post..Did You Know You Can Refund Domain Names?

Gil
November 12, 2008

Thanks Caroline, great post!

I have just recently completed two sites that I have been working on for quite a while, and I’ve just started building backlinks. So you post was perfect timing, I was looking for some other ideas for gaining backlinks.

Gils last blog post..Small Setback – Local Site Being Spammed!

Caroline Middlebrook
November 12, 2008

@Dennis, sorry I misunderstood and to answer that question, the bookmarking site is mostly irrelevant. Google looks at the number of links. If you get 100 links in one day (whether that’s at 100 different sites or 100 links at one site) it will be suspicious and do whatever Google does to discount the links in some way. You have to be mindful of the overall number of links coming in to any particular site. Having said that, it is also better if the links are spread out so its better to have 100 links at 100 different sites than all at one.

@Gil, well keep reading as there are a few more posts in this series to coming on backlinks :-)

Dennis Edell
November 12, 2008

OK then what exactly did you mean by “Only bookmark one page from a domain in one day”, which is what started me on this in the first place. :)

Dennis Edells last blog post..10 Effective Joint Venture Ideas To Get You Started

Caroline Middlebrook
November 13, 2008

@Dennis, well to give you an example… it occurs to me that I have not really followed my own advice for this very blog. I have over 300 posts of content and yet I have not bookmarked many of them. Bookmarking say a dozen posts in one day would be a bad idea because Google would see all those links coming into this domain in one go – so I would only bookmark any one post in any single day. This is something I intend to start doing, starting with my best posts :-)

FH2o
November 13, 2008

Now I understand a little better about link building using social bookmarking. Thanks!

FH2os last blog post..4 Eared Cat

Another great post Caroline. And some great resources too, like 20 site that do follow. Thanks for the tips and the summary at the bottom.

Dennis Edell
November 13, 2008

OK I think I got it lol. Only one article per day, no matter how many sites you submit it too, correct?

How about a routine of say, posting to blog, then submitting to bookmarks……or are there reasons to wait?

Dennis Edells last blog post..10 Effective Joint Venture Ideas To Get You Started

Caroline Middlebrook
November 14, 2008

@Dennis, you got it :-) And yes your routine is just how I did it. Oh and you can work on multiple sites too. So I’d go to one niche site, write a post, bookmark it then do the same at another niche site and so on. I rotated the sites I worked on so every couple of days a site would get some new content and a few incoming links.

Kelly @ Backlinkage
December 7, 2008

Caroline-

I don’t know if you use RSS directories as part of your backlink-building strategy, but if you do, my latest couple of posts might be very enlightening.

-Kelly

P.S. I would have commented on your latest link-building post, but social bookmarking is (slightly) closer to RSS directories than article marketing. ;)

-Kelly

Kelly @ Backlinkages last blog post..RSS Directory Submission – Easy, Semi-Automated, and Free

lorne campbell
December 8, 2008

Hi Caroline
I think as a relative newbie I go with you on the any link is better than no link, in the long run. I pay no attention to follow or indeed nofollow on blogs, I comment on how useful or interesting I find the topic. Yours is as usual good.

BobdeBilder
December 24, 2008

Caroline, in all honesty a simply brilliant post

inspiring to read your frank and purposeful blog

excellent

All4Data
January 22, 2009

Oh boy, I see I am such a dufus above that I can’t even set the correct website address

regarding the 1 link per day, this has always been a standard practise but has never been totally explained?

I develop a Pligg site and one article/news link a day has also been recommended, I suppose it is to stop people simply spamming your site?

Joey Logano
March 17, 2009

Hi Caroline, I have always heard from Google’s Matt Cutts that “easy” links, are not counted by Google, so could it be that links submitted to social bookmarking websites are not counted because they are so easy to get?

Caroline Middlebrook
March 17, 2009

@Joey, there are many grades of links and certainly easy links from social bookmarking will be nowhere near the strength of a high quality link elsewhere but they should still count to some degree.

Ben
May 4, 2009

Caroline, I have a new website that I got about 100 links pointing to it in one day. If Google finds this suspicious and let’s say that they discount or discredit some of these links. Will they ever give any credit to those backlinks in the future?

@Ben, that’s a good question and to be quite honest I don’t know the answer!

ayo
July 4, 2009

Hi Caroline,

How are you? I have been on your site for 60mins(possibly more) going through your articles subscribing and getting all sorts of useful information.
i want to say thanks and i hope i can continually work on the tips you have provided for my blog and practice.
I tried the social marker website now but it kept getting stuck. I guess i would focus on the manual submission for now. I should also mention i am seriously considering the unique article wizard but ….(thats for another day).

above all thanks again
ayo´s last blog ..Be Encouraged Today My ComLuv Profile

Robin @ Full Length Movies
September 15, 2009

I also agree that Bookmarking Demon are promoting spams with their features such as unlimited accounts and use of proxy. Till now I have been using Onlywire bookmarking plugin and I am really satisfied with their service. I came to know about SocialMarker.com only after visiting your blog and will try to use their service because they seem to support more bookmarking sites compared to onlywire.com

Also it great to know that you are going to create your own social bookmarking software. I hope this tool is either free or affordable.
Robin @ Full Length Movies´s last blog ..Watch Sorority Row My ComLuv Profile

Mark
September 29, 2009

Great post, my only query is that Google is beginning to devalue social bookmarking sites and indexing them less and less. Do you think that social bookmarking is still worth the effort?

bobdebilder
September 29, 2009

Social Media is here to stay .. spammy social media will probably die of terminal spam


6 Trackbacks:

Link Building #2 - Web 2.0 Properties | Caroline Middlebrook

[...] Link Building #1 – Social Bookmarking [...]

Link Building #3 - Article Marketing | Caroline Middlebrook

[...] Link Building #1 – Social Bookmarking [...]

Do You Make Link Building Mistakes?

[...] member of social community and when people respect links you submit. In any case, only plus to the purpose of link building is that patience is crucial attribute [...]

Stats & Analysis for November ‘08 - $1,392 Earned | Caroline Middlebrook

[...] Link Building #1 – Social Bookmarking [...]

Link Building #2 - Web 2.0 Properties

[...] last post on link building with social bookmarking is a great way to start building links with very little time and effort. However, you tend to get [...]

Link Building #3 - Article Marketing

[...] don’t write articles to the articles as that could just go on forever! I simply do a round of social bookmarking to the article pages of the articles at the biggest directories such as Ezine articles to give it a [...]

Leave a comment

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

CommentLuv Enabled


Recommended Services
MyBlogLog Community
Top Commentators
Copyright © Caroline MiddlebrookTheme designed by Design Farmer

Twitter links powered by Tweet This v1.6.1, a WordPress plugin for Twitter.