Bluehost

6 Models For Membership Sites and Services

June 30, 2008 Posted under: Making Money Online by Caroline Middlebrook

Last week I compared three revenue models for making money online and concluded that the membership site is the way to go if you want to generate a recurring revenue stream. In this post I present 6 concrete ideas for sites and services that fit this model.

1) Fresh Content For Consumption

Some people need fresh content on a regular basis and if you can provide that content then you can cater to your market for as long as you can come up with the content. Some examples:

  • A PLR site that produces fresh PLR articles
  • Graphics for use in computer games
  • Music for use in all manner of projects

This kind of membership site may tend to generate a high turnover of members as people lose interest in the industry but there will always be other members to take their place. You’ll need to be constantly marketing this kind of site. However to offset this downside, if all of your content is always available to all members your site will become more and more valuable as time goes on and you produce more and more. You might also be able to generate stand-alone products with a sample of your work as an added income stream or as promotional material for the membership site itself.

2) Cutting Edge Information

In some industries, the latest information about how to get ahead is forever changing. A good example would be the Internet Marketing industry! How often do things change in this industry? Search engine algorithms, social media sites, pay per click tactics and so on. The Immediate Edge is an example of a membership site that caters exactly to this market. It is run by Ed Dale and Dan Raine, the two guys behind the Thirty Day Challenge.

In order to make this kind of membership site work it is imperative that you know your industry and you can deliver the goods month after month! It is not sufficient to just slap together a series of articles about a topic and call it a membership site. It needs to be constantly up-to-date, you can never take a few months off. Also, whatever you are teaching or reporting on needs to be accurate. If you feed your members a bunch of bull you will not keep them for long. On the other hand if you really can deliver true cutting edge information in your industry you will have some very loyal members! Examples of possible industries:

  • Internet Marketing or one of the many sub-topics
  • Investing, or other financial information
  • Technology - computer programming, graphic design, digitial photography etc

3) Project Based Teaching

Some people like to learn a skill by example and there are lots of examples of skills that can be taught in projects or lessons that students are able to follow along with. In certain industries there is no limit to the number of projects that you could create and thus as long as your students continued to learn you would be able to keep them as members. For example:

  • Art - drawing, painting, pottery etc
  • Flower Arranging - floristry for weddings, holidays, birthdays etc
  • Cookery - dishes for every occasion
  • Computer Programming - game projects for example

That last example is one that I was going to try myself a few months ago. Like with the fresh content for consumption, with every new project you create you are increasing the value of your site if you make it all available. Alternatively you can package up previous projects and sell them as stand-alone products.

One of my readers runs a membership site along these lines - Banjo Expert which produces many lessons. There is no limit to the number of lessons that could be created for this site.

4) Matching Services

The world is based around supply and demand but very often the people who have the demand and the people who can supply it don’t know how to get together. A matching service brings these two groups of people together. There are lots of examples of this model already working well:

  • Dating / friendship services
  • Buying & Selling such as eBay, Auto Trader etc
  • Recruitment Agencies - matching employees to employers

There are numerous ways in which you can generate an income from these sites. In the examples above dating sites usually charge a flat monthly fee to its members, eBay charges commissions on products sold and most recruitment agencies charge a finders fee to an employer when somebody is hired.

5) Online Tools & Services

With advances in web development technology, software that was previously only available on a desktop computer can now be brought to the web and this has opened up a whole new world of opportunities in web-based software. If you can create (or hire a programmer to create it for you) a tool that provides a valuable service you can charge a fee to use it and keep members for as long as they want to use the software. I use many of these myself, for example:

  1. Weight Loss Resources is a calorie database with a food planning element
  2. Allakhazam is a comprehensive database for the online game World of Warcraft
  3. Vitalist is a task management service based on GTD

The last two on the list have both a free and a premium (paid) version so of course the free version is used as a pre-seller for the premium version. If you have access to the skills required to produce this kind of service then you can be onto a winner because once the software is written, little maintenance is usually required. Of course, somebody else can just come along and copy your idea so you will also need to keep your software up-to-date and keep on top of your marketing efforts.

6) Access to an Expert

This is often presented in the form of coaching around a particular topic. Usually there is a sense of community built into it. This kind of membership site is tricky to pull off unless you have already established yourself as an expert in your particular niche but if you have already done that with a successful info product perhaps, then this is a good way of converting your expertise into an ongoing income stream. Some example of people who have done this:

  • Tom Venuto released a book Burn the Fat, Feed the Muscle and later released the Burn the Fat Inner Circle
  • Jeff Walker released his Product Launch Formula and now has the PLF Inner Sanctum

Any Others?

I’m sure there are lots more ideas that I haven’t thought of. Can you think of any? I would also be interested to hear from those of you who currently run a membership site. Does it fit into one of the models above or is it something else?

If you've enjoyed reading this post then please subscribe to my Full Text RSS Feed.


Stumble it!

You might also like these similar posts:

Making Money With Ebooks, Courses & Membership Sites - Which is Best?
Articles
Teaching Sells Review & Sneak Peek Video
Don’t Get Scammed By Promises of Big Bucks
Free = A Bigger Audience? Not Necessarily…

18 Comments:

Jacob from JobMob
June 30, 2008

Terrific roundup, Caroline. I’m just about to graduate Yaro’s MSM and you’ve given me some extra food for future project thought.

I Stumbled this

Jacob from JobMobs last blog post..First JobMob Pro Chat: Payroll Specialist Moshe Egel-Tal, July 15th 2008

Louise BJ
June 30, 2008

Thanks Caroline, your list is very comprehensive and includes areas I hadn’t thought of as being candidates for membership sites. I’m planning to start my own soon so your post is timely. Thanks again.
Louise

JoLynn Braley
June 30, 2008

Hi Caroline,

Saw your tweet, these are really great ideas, a way to help open the mind to the possibilities of creating a membership site, especially if you would like to do that but haven’t been sure just what kind you could offer.

Thanks a lot, bookmarking this for the future…

;)

JoLynn Braleys last blog post..Fit Links and Weight Loss Success Stories at The Fit Shack

Steve Mills
July 1, 2008

Good roundup of different styles of membership sites Caroline, thanks for getting my brain ticking over and looking for more possibilities. I have a few projects in development, and it is an interesting question to ask, does this work better as a one off course, or should I develop the content a bit further and turn it into a membership site?

Steve Millss last blog post..Sustainable Personal Online Connected Entrepreneur

bloggernoob
July 1, 2008

do you have any membership sites caroline? Was curious about the ones you own and operate. the income generated from those etc.

bloggernoobs last blog post..BradBlogging.com

Patrik
July 1, 2008

The problem, as I see it, with membership sites or “expert advise sites” is that it take some time to generate needed trust in the niche. When “status is accomplished” a payed membership area is much easier to promote and gain recurring income from

/Patrik

Jade Craven
July 1, 2008

I was going to ask the same as bloggernoob. Skellie wrote something recently about membership sites and it does seem like a useful way. Are you intending to go down this path and would you blog this aspect of your journey?

The membership model that attracts me most is to base a course or membership site around a different product.

Would you be expanding on any of these models in a future post?

Something that interests me is that your still earning income for the e-book you wrote last year. Wouldn’t a viable possibility be to develop a new e-book say, once every 6 months or year? Perhaps rather than plug an affiliate product you could plug a membership site but just in a different way.

Massimo Gaetani
July 1, 2008

Once more great post Caroline. What I like mostly is that it summarize in a succinct and precise way information that would require a long time to put together.

Massimo Gaetanis last blog post..Defend yourself in 3 lessons: one more thing some people don’t know about martial arts

Ruchir Chawdhry
July 1, 2008

When it comes to membership sites, I prefer the project based training model. Other models either require too much work (cutting edge model) or require to much marketing to start rolling (matching services model).

And a project based training model also has relatively low upkeep, compared to the others…

Hosting Review
July 1, 2008

Membership site, it’s so far for me :-D

Hosting Reviews last blog post..Register.com

@Jacob, yes same here so I have membership sites on the brain hehe.

@Steve, I have seen several cases of a membership site that should have been left as a course. In my opinion, you should not create a membership site unless you can sustain the content indefinitely. If you have a finite amount of content then what happens when that runs out? It sounds like the topics you have content for should be courses.

@bloggernoob, no I don’t have much of anything at the moment! I’m toying with an idea for one but if I do run with the idea it won’t be until September at the earliest.

@Patrik, yes that is a good point. Very often the earlier products such as ebooks or courses can help you to establish that authority.

@Jade, I will share on here everything that I use to make money so yes if I create a membership site you can be sure that I’ll be blogging about it extensively. I would like to be create something along these lines because I would really like to create an income stream that is fairly steady so I can take the plunge and buy my own home.

Creating one-off products on a regular basis is another alternative but there is always the danger of simply running out of ideas. My ideal would be to have one or two regular income streams that take up no more than 50% of my time and then still create one-off products on the side.

@Ruchir, hmm maybe but to continue to provide fresh value to your members you would need to continue to produce new projects so there will still be an element of on-going work.

nudgeme
July 1, 2008

Really useful list Caroline and great timing as I’m currently contemplating developing a membership site. My research into these so far seem to suggest pricing something within easy reach of most people eg, regular tips, pieces of writing etc which can be put together in advance as a means of building up trust and relationships, but then also maybe a higher end membership model such as a platinum programme offering one on one coaching x times a year or a retreat or something similar. I like the idea of offering a range of membership options to suit all pockets as a means of keeping people interested and moving from one option to the next.

Thanks for another great post, it’s really helped my thinking.

Hendry Lee
July 1, 2008

I think you round it up, but a few twists I see regularly:

- A membership offering marketing strategies (not necessarily new but the members like to be spoon fed.

- Access to a group of people (inner circle), i.e. experts or otherwise. Many people need others for hold them accountable, not only to gain expert’s information.

Hendry Lees last blog post..8 Ways to Hook Blog Readers with Your Post Title

@nudgeme, I have removed your second comment as the link you provided didn’t work but thanks for the thought :)

@Hendry, the spoon feeding is something I would lump into the first category of fresh content for consumption. Generally people who need spoon feeding continue to need spoon feeding :)

John Farina
July 3, 2008

Great post Caroline.

James
July 3, 2008

I think there can be alot of power in having interviews with other experts in the field. Say you have a marketing membership site. Each month providing a new area to learn. You could bring in a guest each month who you interview (admitting you know more than most about this area but that person is the expert to the experts) and then your teaching can be around what they go over in the interview. It makes content creation easier and you increase value by letting people know you got the best of the best.

Web Design Glasgow
July 3, 2008

SEOMoz is a great example of this. They started out with a blog, and established themselves as a knowledge hub, the experts, in the field of SMO. Then they started releasing free eBooks, paid books or a membership with free access to the paid eBooks and further tools, etc. Their latest move as far as I’m aware was to offer ‘Access to the experts’ as part of this membership.

@James, oh yes that’s an excellent idea! I’m not sure if it would be strong enough to be the entire basis of a membership site though.

@Web Design, I think they converted the SEO ‘book’ into a paid membership rather than constantly updating the book version.


1 Trackbacks:

Father Sez » Archive » Is this an opportunity staring me in my face, or just fools’ gold?

[...] reading in Caroline’s blog about the 3 revenue models for making money online. The membership site model (one of these 3), was further elaborated upon by Caroline in a subsequent [...]

Leave a comment

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>



Recommended Services
MyBlogLog Community
Top Commentators
Copyright © Caroline MiddlebrookTheme designed by Design Farmer